Attorney(s) for Plaintiff:
David A. Barry
Sugarman,Rogers,Barshack & Cohen
$975,000 CONFIDENTIAL RECOVERY – MEDICAL MALPRACTICE – ORTHOPEDIC SURGERY – FAILURE TO TIMELY DIAGNOSE AND TREAT COMPARTMENT SYNDROME IN 18-YEAR-OLD – LOSS OF MUSCLE – SIGNIFICANT SCARRING TO RIGHT LOWER LEG.
Withheld County, MA
In this medical malpractice matter, the plaintiff patient alleged that the defendant orthopedic surgeon was negligent in failing to timely diagnose and treat compartment syndrome. As a result, the 18-year-old suffered permanent muscle damage and significant scarring. The defendant denied any deviation from acceptable standards of care and disputed causation and damages.
The 18-year-old male plaintiff from Montreal, Quebec, attended a private high school in Maine where he was an accomplished hockey player. On September 14, 2013 he fractured his right tibia during a soccer game and was taken to a local hospital. The emergency room physician performed a closed reduction and applied the plaster splint/cast. The plaintiff was, at that time, in pain; his right foot was purple in color and he was unable to feel his big toe. The defendant orthopedic surgeon saw the plaintiff at approximately 6 p.m. and admitted him to the hospital planning to operate on his right leg the next morning. By 9 p.m., the plaintiff's pain was severe and constant. He experienced numbness on the top half of his foot and could only slightly move his bit toe. The nurse notified the defendant, who instructed the nursing staff to apply ice, elevate the plaintiff's leg and to cut his ACE bandage, "If needed to reduce pressure." The nurse contacted the defendant surgeon again at 10 p.m., one hour later, when the plaintiff was complaining of pain and spasm in his calf. The defendant ordered Valium for the plaintiff as needed. Even with the pain medication, the plaintiff was unable to sleep and complained of severe pain. By 5 a.m., the plaintiff's foot was swollen, numb and he was unable to move it.
When the defendant removed the plaintiff's splint in the operating room at 7:30 a.m. the following morning, he noted that the plaintiff had a dysvascular foot with no capillary refill and no Doppler pulse below his knee. The defendant performed a partial fasciotomy and identified brisk bleeding from a lacerated tibial artery at the site of the tibial fracture. After the defendant performed an open reduction and applied an external fixator, the plaintiff was transferred to UMass Medical Center for urgent vascular evaluation.
He remained there for six days and underwent three operations to restore the blood flow to the muscles and nerves of his right lower leg and complete the repair of the fracture.
On September 21, the plaintiff was stable enough to be transported to a hospital near his home in Montreal. From that time until November, the plaintiff underwent a series of operations to remove necrotic muscle and infected tissue from his right leg and for skin grafting. His multiple infections were treated with antibiotics and in August 2014, he underwent yet another surgery to replace the intramedullary nail that had been inserted with an antibiotic coated nail. His final surgery was in January 2015 to remove the antibiotic coated nail. It was then followed by six weeks of intravenous antibiotics. The plaintiff brought suit against the defendant orthopedic surgeon alleging negligence. The plaintiff alleged that during the evening of September 14, and the early morning hours of September 15, the plaintiff demonstrated signs and symptoms consistent with acute compartment syndrome. The plaintiff's condition was not treated, as it should have been, as a medical emergency by the defendant. The plaintiff maintained that if the defendant was negligent in failing to examine the plaintiff and rule out compartment syndrome.
The defendant denied the allegations. The defendant surgeon maintained that there was no deviation from acceptable standards of care. The defendant argued that any delay in diagnosing the plaintiff's compartment syndrome did not cause or contribute to his alleged damages.The parties agreed to resolve the plaintiff's claim for the sum of $975,000 in damages in a confidential settlement prior to the trial in this matter.
Plaintiff's orthopedic surgery expert: Michael Baumgartner, M.D. from New Haven, CT.
Plaintiff Patient Doe vs. Defendant Orthopedic Surgeon., 08-05-16.
Attorney for plaintiff: David A. Barry of Sugarman Rogers Barshack & Cohen in Boston, MA.
As Published by:
Jury Verdict Review Publications, Inc.
45 Springfield Ave.
Springfield, NJ 07081-9770
Phone: (973) 376-9002
Fax: (973) 376-1775